Sunday, September 20, 2009

Assignment #2

When considering that all three of these videos are intended for the young audience, I can’t help but immediately consider the drastic changes in roles, relationships and sex throughout the past several decades. More specifically, how the focus point of relationships for youth are sexual acts. From the bubbly, heart-ache sob story of the ruined birthday party of Gore’s video to the free distribution of sex in Lil’ Kim’s video, we see drastically different portrayals of women. As much as women try to find power and happiness through relationships and men, I think men still have the control in the videos.

It’s quit ironic this week we are analyzing gender roles in music videos, as I was just recently thinking about the impact these messages have on young people. I am “friends” with my 15 year-old cousin on facebook, and have to say, sometimes I wonder if I should be! For being 15, she definitely is not afraid to post some “flirty” pictures or proclaim her liking for boys. I keep thinking where this influence to be “flirty” on facebook is coming from….her parents? Her friends? Society? More importantly, I wonder if she realizes what she is doing or is just doing it because it’s the “cool thing to do” and society (or Lil Kim videos!) is telling her to be like that. It’s disturbing.

It’s My Party:

This video obviously portrays a much more conservative time in our nation’s history, especially when comparing it to the Lil Kim’s video! For Gore, she simply distraught that Jonny leaves the party and comes back holding Judy’s hand. It’s ironic she’s singing about being so sad and heart-broken when she has a big smile on her face during the video! For her, happiness comes in getting Jonny and wearing that ring. “Til Jonny’s dancing with me, I’ve got no reason to smile.” Jonny ruined her party. This obviously reflects a male dominance/power over women. Young girls seek that affirmation and attention from boys, especially amongst her friends. When I asked my mom about this song, she just easily belted out the main chorus! Obviously, she didn’t pay much attention to the meaning behind the lyrics nor could recite them. However, if this song were to reflect the time period, it would obviously reveal a male dominance/control over young women’s happiness and emotions.


Criminal:

The accompanying article by Zeltner provides an in-depth analysis of Criminal; so many images and perspectives to address with this video! This is a video that was popular when I was in high school; I specifically remember my friend wearing a Fiona Apple t-shirt, portraying that Fiona was a “musical genius!” I do know the history/background of Fiona Apple, and therefore, am a bit hesitant with what to address with the video. However, in general, this video again shows the women trying to find happiness/power through sexual acts but in the end simply “Feeling like a criminal.” I did find it interesting that the beginning images of the video included a stuffed animal, which reflects a youth and innocence to Fiona. Again, later in the video, she is in the closet with pig-tails, illustrating her youth and yet showing she is only good enough to be in a closet as a possession. As Zeltner stated, “This entire montage of shots portrays Apple as something less than a possession. She is someone who is reduced to hiding in the closet or the bathroom. The early thrill of voyeurism that was encouraged in the opening seconds of the video now begins to sour.” Even though Fiona was trying to find power and pleasure through men and sex, again, she was found powerless. Men still dominated in the end and she “feels like a criminal.”


‘Lil Kim How Many Licks

Wow! No wonder my 15 year cousin isn’t afraid to post bikini pictures on facebook!! At first, I thought this video portrayed women as the one in control, being able to find whoever she wants and when! But the more I thought about it, it truly does say that sex sells and in doing this, portrays a message to young girls to be like reproducible machines. Immediately in the beginning are images of women as dolls being made in the factory. Words flash across the screen: “Full Edible, Candy Kills, Full Range of Motion, State and Federal Prison Approved.” Men can order women like dolls to perform any sort of sexual desire needed. Towards the end of the song, the lyrics include “Some niggaz even put me on their grocery lists
right next to the whip cream and box of chocolates.” While Lil Kim does act as if she’s in control throughout the video, she’s portraying this idea that power comes through being a male sex toy.



Additionally, I thought it was interesting how Lil Kim reinforces the racial stereotypes in the video. The first man she references was a white male who “buy me a horse, a Porsche and a farm.” Then, the video often flashed images of the African American males behind bars in a jail cell. African American males who were referenced as being in jail as well as portrayed in jail in the video. Again, this portrayal to a young audience reveals and reinforces the racial divide in America found in income, wealth, and jailed inmates.

In summary, all three videos portray women as finding happiness and power through men. While the role and importance of sex has changed throughout history, it is still the idea that men control women's happiness. Today, sex sells. With Fiona stripping and almost naked to Lil Kim strutting around in high heels fish-nets tights, girls are seeking this reassurance, acceptance, and power from men. When in the end, the men always have the power.

Well...to add to the many videos that other classmates have posted, I love the how Beyonce portrays male/female roles in "If I were a boy." She uses role reversal to portray gender stereotypes and puts an interesting twist on male dominance in a relationship. Worth a watch!


No comments:

Post a Comment